What she did say was this:. But the court must also recognize the limits on itself and respect the choices made by the American people. Kagan may not have had gay marriage in mind when she made that statement, but it could not be more relevant. While the Senate considers Ms. Whatever he decides is likely to be appealed, presumably up to the court that Ms.
Does It Matter Whether Elena Kagan Is Gay? - The American Prospect
She definitely dated when she was in D. The rumor about Kagan has circulated for months on gay blogs and became a matter of controversy when it was cited as fact by a conservative blogger on the website of CBS News, drawing a sharp White House rebuttal. It has, since, been a source of particular fascination in some socially conservative circles and particularly among gay and lesbian political observers, some of whom objected volubly Tuesday to a Wall Street Journal cover image of Kagan playing softball, which they perceived as a jab at a stereotype of lesbians. The result has been an awkward dilemma for the traditional media, for whom reporting about homosexuality has always been considered to be off limits. Reporters and bloggers have debated, publicly and privately, the propriety of asking whether Kagan is gay. The intense scrutiny that comes with a Supreme Court nomination leaves ample space for curiosity — particularly intense in the gay community— on a question that even leading Republican Senators have dismissed as irrelevant to the job.
Elena Kagan 's name was on nearly every shortlist that was published in the days following Justice John Paul Stevens' announcement that this term would be his last on the Supreme Court. In the weeks that followed, there was a fair amount of speculation about Kagan's sexual orientation. CBS blogger Ben Domenech wrote , almost in passing, that she would be the "first openly gay justice. But I'm not interested in whether she's gay. I'm interested in whether it matters.
She isn't, according to a White House official, suggesting that a rumor campaign was being waged to trip up a potential Court candidacy. She's also described as potentially the "first openly gay justice. Domenech later added an addendum stating, "I have to correct my text here to say that Kagan is apparently still closeted -- odd, because her female partner is rather well known in Harvard circles. Then CBSNews.